Failure Analysis
The approach to failure analysis at Dayton T. Brown, Inc. is unique and unparalleled by other engineering
houses, especially during the critical early evaluation stage.
DTB can bring to bear a broad range of failure analysis expertise that can be pulled into the process quickly and
efficiently.
A quick failure analysis consultation with an electrical, test, or structural engineer
can provide key insights into a components’ failure modes and on how to improve
the design or manufacturing process.
Please refer to the Library of Failure Analyses on this site to see examples of how a focused failure analysis can lead to product design improvements.
The following steps of a product failure analysis are based on a metallurgical failure analysis procedure, but have been adapted to provide
key insights into other types of components as shown in the library of failure analysis reports.
DTB’s 8-Step Failure Analysis Process for Metallurgical Issues
Note: For “Non-Metallurgical Failures”, other engineering disciplines would be integrated.
1.) Background
It is vital to obtain as much background information as possible about a failed item and its design and intended use.
- Engineering Drawing Requirements
- Physical Interfaces
- Typical Service Environment
- Evaluation of N+1 components
2.) Failure History
Information specific to the actual environment is also vital to the failure analysis, especially when compared to the nominal design requirements and configurations.
- Failure-specific Customer Feedback
- Previous Failure History
- Actual Service Environment
- Exceptions and Anomalies
3.) External and Non-destructive evaluation
Overall examination of the component is performed in the "as received" condition through
the use of high resolution digital imaging, liquid penetrant or magnetic particle
flaw detection, x-ray imaging, and other non-destructive failure analysis methods.
- General Appearance
- Surface Roughness, Shot Peening, Coatings, Edge Breaks, Reworking…
- Mechanical Damage, Fretting, Corrosion, Erosion, Debris, Spalling, Discoloration, Arcing…
- Primary and Secondary Fractures
4.) Fractographic Analysis
Examination on a more detailed basis of the fracture surfaces using failure analysis tools such as stereomicroscopy,
scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS).
- Macro- and Micro-Fractography
- Fracture Topography, Angle Changes, Fracture Modes, Fracture mode Transitions, Initiation and Propagation, Shear Lips, Fretting, Coating Damage, Secondary Cracks, Microcracks, Striations…
5.) Metallographic Analysis
For failure analysis of metallic components there is no substitute for experience and
our metallurgical staff has examined literally thousands of failure surfaces. They
will quickly focus in the salient aspects of the failure analysis problem by examining the following:
- Macrostructure and Microstructure
- Grain Flow, Composition, Hardness, Precipitation, Inclusions, Grain Boundary Networks, Microcracks, Surface/subsurface Defects, Coating / Plating Degradation, Corrosion, Fretting, Intergranular Fracture, Stress Corrosion Cracking
6.) Failure Cascade Determination
By utilizing insights from the entire DTB engineering staff and detailed observations from the failure analysis a cascade
of events leading to the failure can often be determined.
- Stress Analysis
- Microstructural Failure Analysis
- Fractographic Failure Analysis
- Non Destructive Evaluations
7.) Isolation of Root Causes
Using insight gained from the failure analysis of the failed component, as well
as fundamental engineering insights from decades of experience, the root cause of
the failure is determined and recommendations for Failure Prevention are formulated.
8.) Recommendations for Failure Prevention
After completing the failure analysis, our Design Engineering staff can provide various viable product improvement measures
based on input from you on costs, complexity and reliability requirements. In our testing business we see product failures every week, thus we have developed an inherent
expertise in making corrective design recommendations for many different products
in many different markets.